Welcome Guest [Log In] [Register]

Viewing Single Post From: American Idol Adds Fourth Judge for New Season
Member Avatar

Aug 26 2008, 05:14 AM
One problem with this is that they'll have to spend even more time getting the judges critiques on each episode, and does anybody really care what they think, in the end? I feel like they're always told what to say ahead of time, anyway. Just like Paula last year, mistakenly critiquing a song that wasn't even performed.

They should just fire Paula and stick this new bitch in her place.
True that we really don't care what they have to say. Simon is the only one that has some decent advice. It maybe harsh, but it is constructive. Last year became a competition between Simon and Randy. There were times Randy would say something, Simon wouldn't agree with it. There were many times when Randy made a comment based to getting a shot at Simon for not agreeing with him on a previous performer. And there are not enough words to explain how useless Paula is.

Still mixed on a fourth judge because I don't care about wasting time on a fourth opinion, but if it is constructive like Simon's then it will work. It will be one of those things we will have to wait and see.
Offline Profile Quote Post
American Idol Adds Fourth Judge for New Season · Primetime Discussion