ladyofthelake

Nov 9 2008, 10:02 PM

Amello

Nov 9 2008, 09:58 PM

mesagirl

Nov 9 2008, 09:47 PM

I never really warmed up to Brandon Beemer as Shawn. I'll forever associate JC with that role. Martha was amazing of course. I think we all agree about that. BTW, Kirsten Storms... is great on GH as Maxie.

I think the main problem with me regarding Brandon, wasn't so much Brandon but how they were writing Shawn to be as dumb as a stick during that time.

I hate the character of Shawn Brady. All the writers ever did was make him this huge caricature. Boring to the hilt, he was. I hope if Martha comes back as Belle, praying they don't stupidly recast for nothing, Shawn is left behind. Yes, I feel he could be an important part of the future of the show but so many other character are much more layered. It doesn't help I was a total Phelle fan.

Hey, now see, Amello, I DO have taste. I was a Phelle fan even with Kyle Brandt, even before they even hinted at Shimi. ;)