Viewing Single Post From: SOW: A Closer Look: Melanie
Feb 17 2009, 01:43 AM
- Elite Member
- June 16, 2007
- Favorite Current Daytime Soap Opera
- Favorite Soap Opera of All Time
- Favorite Current Primetime Soap Opera
- Gossip Girl/Vampire Diaries
I totally agree with you. For a long time, I was even willing to buy her as a mature 18 year old. Chelsea came off as fairly immature in the Daniel relationship, but I thought Melanie could hold her own - after all, age is just a number.
- Feb 12 2009, 09:15 AM
- Feb 11 2009, 05:11 PM
Molly Burnett was fairly good in the beginning back when we thought she was Nick's new love interest. I never thought in a million years her story would revolve around guys in their thirties like Philip and EJ and that she'd playing her own rules. It's not fair to the actress either who is too inexperienced for such a storyline and we wind up unjustly disliking her character more for it.
Melanie as a young but "bad" girl who was used by her father was a decent storyline. But Molly Burnett is absolutely miscast now Melanie is apparently a spitfire heartbreaker who has business sense that apparently equals or surpasses men from both the Kiriakis and Dimera empire.
IA with everything you've posted except I don't think Molly has been miscast. I think the problem is that the character is supposed to be 18 and that makes the character misplaced in the EJ/Phillip scenes. I suspect that the story is too flawed for any actress to overcome.
Because of this ridiculous fuel story she's going to seem too old to be in scenes with Will and Mia now so all of the other characters will be too old or too young for her to interact with. They could bring in actors in her age group but I find that prospect annoying because they got rid of Blake Berris.
I tuned in briefly today, and Melanie just seemed way too young all of a sudden. The scene I am referring to is one with Philip - her hair looked ridiculous too, LOL. It seems to me they are regretting writing her as 18 - I don't see why they did that in the first place, though. Was it to play up the fact her father had legal rights surrounding her schooling etc.? Or was it to have her be a love interest for Will? She will definitely seem too old in scenes in that sense, since I still do think of her was wise beyond her years (to an extent). Whatever the case, it does seem like they are trying to write her as this hot and sexy 20-something but she can't play that...if that's the kind of character they wanted, they should have cast it.