Viewing Single Post From: New Ed Scott Interview!
Jun 24 2009, 01:27 PM
- Elite Member
- July 2, 2007
I think that Scott wanted Philip/Morgan, Higley wanted Philip/Chloe, and then Tomlin wants Philip/Stephanie. It was obvious, before Tomlin/Whitesell got total control on the show, that Higley was heading for Philip/Chloe again, and also she seemed to want a Chelsea/Nick/Melanie triangle, maybe Lumi again, amongst some other things.
- Jun 24 2009, 01:00 PM
- Jun 24 2009, 11:07 AM
- Jun 24 2009, 10:58 AM
- Jun 24 2009, 02:06 AM
The plane crash sequence was excellent, but a lot of younger viewers like myself were turned off by his treatment of Philip & Chloe and especially throwing Chloe into a "romance" with Lucas while ignoring her history with Brady.
Was that Ed Scott? It seems like Higley to me. Especially since the whole Dr. Dan thing. Brady is around. If Higley wanted to do some justice, the actors are there.
Actually, there was initially some good Philip/Chloe stuff during the plane crash. It wasn't until somebody started pushing Philip and Morgan that Chloe was thrown towards Lucas. Given that KR was fired shortly after Ed Scott was, it seems clear to me that Scott was the one who wanted Renton featured in a front-burner romance. As to why they didn't revisit Broe, that's a different question, but I assume by that point they had already decided to try out Danloe.
My speculation is if Danloe hadn't worked out Shawn and Nadia would both have been gone shortly thereafter, since it sure seemed as if Nadia was almost fired back when she was leaving town for the opera in wherever. There was also uncertainty about Jay's contract status last fall and whether he would renew. I have speculated Philip was initially paired with Stephanie with the thought that if Jay didn't renew, it was easier to deal with a short-term romance than to be writing a long-term Phloe story, or what passes for one these days. Again, this is all my speculation and I'm not claiming any backstage knowledge, just guessing based on what I've seen onscreen.
Once again, I'm in total agreement with your statements, Paxton. Nelson Branco recently reported on KR getting a role on a different show and referred to her as ES's pet in the article. I have no doubt that ES is the one who pushed Morgan front and center against Higley's wishes (she had been reuniting Phloe, which Sheffer hadn't been doing, starting with the plane crash and Ireland stuff) because the first thing Higley did when she got control was fire KR and have Philip declare his love for Chloe.
I also agree that with contracts up in the air the show went different routes than they originally intended - putting Philip in a possible romance with Stephanie that would have been very easy to yank him out of if JKJ left, or to if they had to recast. And when Whitesell came along, despite noting Phloe's chemistry, I think he wanted to keep the stories going in one direction since they had been all over the place for so long so he kept Chloe in her triangle from hell and Philip with his age-inappropriate love interests.
Then Tomlin seemed to scrap most of that...but its obvious that Higley and Scott majorly disagreed on visions. Now, I honestly think Tomlin and Higley don't see eye to eye either, but Ed and Higley's struggles seemed to be very, very bad...Ed's best time was when he and Hogan were working together....2008 was just a mess for Days.