Welcome Guest [Log In] [Register]

Viewing Single Post From: Britney Spears Signs X Factor Deal!
Member Avatar

May 15 2012, 01:29 AM
I don't know how much the judges actually do on the X Factor (they didn't show much of it), but last season the judges sure liked to get digs in at each other when the song choice wasn't great or if they didn't like changes made to it. They have be working with these people in some capacity. Even if they don't do any of that, Britney judging singing talent is funny.

They do work with them on the 'The Voice'. We see it.
I know they work with them on The Voice. My point is that it's highly unlikely that the judges/mentors choose the song and work out the arrangements every week for their artists. That's my point. They may some weeks but whatever ideas they do have have to run out at some point. Sure, they oversee what their artists do but I think it's a collaborative process between the singer, judge/mentor, record producers/execs, vocal coaches, etc. That is why I think you can get away with having judges/mentors on these shows that aren't even good singers or not singers/performers at all. The record execs know far more about song choice and arrangements than the judge/mentors that are performers anyway. That much has been demonstrated on these shows.
Offline Profile Quote Post
Britney Spears Signs X Factor Deal! · Primetime News & Spoilers