Viewing Single Post From: Historical Clip Discussion #6: Nightmare at Graceland, 1997
The Room Stops
Aug 3 2012, 05:18 PM
- Elite Member
- October 11, 2007
- Twitter ID
Oh yeah yeah yeah. I mean the wedding specifically.
- Aug 3 2012, 02:47 PM
Here are my thoughts on that. JER changed characters, BUT he did so consistently. If his view of Sami Brady was not the same as the view of previous writers, then his view won. Same for Kate, and same for John Black. But, given that, John Black was written as a solid, consistent character with consistent motivations throughout JER's stories. I agree with you, I didn't like that John was so naive. I would have preferred the angst-ridden, troubled, warm-hearted man we met in 1986. But I MUCH prefer JER's style to anyone after him who wrote plot-driven garbage and changed the characters on a whim to match the story.
Same with Marlena - in JER's eyes she was a beautiful, ethereal, princess in distress type. Viewers may have missed the Marlena of the 80's who had more initiative and spark (though IMO Deidre played both versions incredibly well.) But given that that's how JER saw her, he wrote the stories beautifully around that theme.
I didn't see Marlena as the damsel in distress, even in the 90s. She saved John as many times as he saved her. My problem with JER was pretty much John related, and specifically the wedding. I didn't even mind that he didn't know it was Susan... he was fantasizing about Marlena anyway, so we know why he didn't notice. It was the wedding specifically.
And that we basically got no reunion. Too. Fast.