Viewing Single Post From: Wednesday, November 14th Daily Discussion
Nov 14 2012, 01:16 PM
- January 16, 2009
Yes he can stay Catholic and give up his preisthood, BUT in turn Nicole turns into the woman who manipulated a priest by the good people of Salem. Sorry not a storyline I find appealing but then I really haven't had one that did fall into that catergory for about 5 years now.
- Nov 14 2012, 12:38 PM
- Nov 14 2012, 12:32 PM
- Nov 14 2012, 12:05 PM
- Nov 14 2012, 11:48 AM
Quoting limited to 4 levels deep
You know there have been real cases of Catholic priests that have had relationships (and even children) with women (here is one example: http://www.reuters.com/article/2009/05/28/us-usa-priest-idUSTRE54R70020090528
) , who then went on to convert and they were able to marry in their new religion and continue to serve God.
If Eric was shown not to love Nicole EVER then I can see what you were saying and even then, priests are human, they commit sins like everyone else, they CAN fall in love and have. IMHO it's a very good story to tell, very soapy and something that can touch on realism. My preference would be that they tell this story as Eric after years of feeling empty and not finding anyone who he can love as much as Nicole decided to embrace God. It gave him comfort and helped him move on with his life. Now he's back and realizes he never stopped loving Nicole and seeking God was only a way to have him forget her and it never worked. He then has to deal with not only the re-emergence of his feelings for Nicole but also his betrayal of God and the church.
Likie I said pick another religion, Catholic's are always USED for this kind of story. So in your soapy story he has to give up his TRUE religion and chose another so he can screw Nicole. Sorry again as a Catholic I find it repulsive, I don't appreciate my religion being used like this. But then again I guess some find it all soapy and want to tune in for it obviously, but then that's a topic for a whole other board - there is an old saying NEVER talk Politics or Religion it can be a very touchy subject. So if as a Catholic I don't appreciate my religion being used excuse me. :shame:
He doesn't have to give up his religion. He would have to give up the priesthood, but he wouldn't have to stop being Catholic to be involved with Nicole.