- Elite Member
- August 8, 2008
Kayla had reasons for what she did...all the way down the line.
- Sep 27 2013, 05:50 PM
- Sep 27 2013, 04:46 PM
- Sep 27 2013, 04:43 PM
- Panda Panda
- Sep 27 2013, 04:32 PM
I don't see how having Jack back would help JJ not hate him for what he did? Jack raped Kayla. There's no justification, no "other side", and no explanation behind his assault. And there shouldn't be.
I'm not too fond of the fact that this storyline is skating on the fringes of Fetch break/makeup #267253625362, but if the writers can somehow keep this story about JJ, Kayla, Jack, and Jennifer (ONLY THEM) then I wouldn't mind seeing how everything plays out
I don't think that's the point of having Jack back. It wouldn't keep JJ from hating him, but that is where the drama comes in. I just think having this story without Jack being involved at all is ....just wrong. It's going to all be about Daniel, and how JJ starts to accept him. That isn't at all what this should all be about. But I don't know any other reason to bring this all up when one of the key characters isn't even around. To me, it is a waste of a story without Jack. Sure, it might be a good story for a day or two, but if Jack were actually around....they could milk it for a whole lot more than what it will probably end up being.
The complaint would still be that it's all about Daniel even if Jack were there. Jack being there wouldn't affect that one little bit. It would affect other things, but not that. If they were misrepresenting the history, I could empathize with the outcry over this. But they're not. This is what happened and it's what happened
whether Jack is alive or dead. The drama comes not from Jack having to defend himself but from his son learning the truth. And that's what we're getting at this point.
But a lot of things happened back then. And many of those things were interconnected. I am concerned that if these writers only pull out part of the story for their own purposes, there will be a tendency for many to be misled by the new telling (or the inadequate telling).
Let's look at this way. We all know that Jack raped Kayla. Many of us actually saw that played out onscreen. It was wrenching and horrible. We saw the act (well, kind of), and we saw the aftermath as it affected both Jack and Kayla -- and others around them. It definitely "happened."
We also saw the events leading up to it, including when Kayla was shown to carry on an affair with Steve behind her husband's back, and lying to Jack for months. This also "happened."
Now, let's say that a few years from now, a new writing team decides to kill off Kayla and later tell a coming of age story about her son Joey. And let's say they decide he finds out that his mom was a lying, cheating woman who cuckolded her first husband -- perhaps because the writers want to diminish Kayla in the eyes of her son.
I would be incensed and enraged that a writing team would cynically take something that was so powerful and exploit it and twist it like that.
I am NOT excusing what Jack did. I am NOT saying that JJ shouldn't find out the truth. But what I am saying is that I don't want these writers to be the ones to bring it back up. They have given me no confidence whatsoever that they can handle the kind of complexity this warrants. Worse, I'm concerned that the "accepted canon" of what transpired will be altered by their mucking around in it.
I think she was wrong in some of her decisions, but I understood why she made the decisions she did, even though I didn't agree with them.
If you have access to the whole story, you see Jack is very sick (Hodgkin's Disease), and it's thought that he's dying. Kayla's his friend, but she doesn't love him, because she's already given her heart to Steve. However, Jack's in a bad way, and everyone around Jack, from Harper to Angelica to Mike Horton (Jack's doctor) become very concerned about his attitude and lack of "fight." Even Melissa, who loves Jack, wants Jack to live badly enough that she doesn't say much against the marriage anywhere...because Jack wants Kayla, and if he wants Kayla, maybe he should have her, so he'll live.
Kayla gets a lot of pressure to accept Jack's marriage proposal, from well-meaning people who want Jack to fight harder to live. Jack even tells Melissa that if he doesn't have the hope of a future with Kayla, what's the point of living anyway?
Sometimes I wish Kayla had said to heck with it and disregarded that proposal, friendship or not. Jack never should have proposed to her anyway. He KNEW she loved Steve, and there he was in that hospital bed...How do you say no to a guy who everyone is concerned is going to die?
But she didn't say no. She married him. Her decision. An unhappy one for her...and when she finds out the truth, it becomes even MORE complicated and messy.